
It feels like at least a little bit of magic that Ingrid Newkirk, president and co-founder of PETA, spoke at Powell's in Portland last night. What gorgeous timing! Thanks to smart phones, social networking sites and frantic tip-offs from proactive, feminist friends, we were able to pull off a flash protest at Ms. Newkirk's talk (in about 1.5 hours, no less!). Though so much of last night was a heartbreaking disappointment, more of it was inspired, moving and ultimately worth the emotional roller coaster of taking a stand against fat phobia in a fat body. Everyone that came to protest PETA's sexist and sizeist ad campaigns was articulate, well-spoken and respectful, despite some taunts and jeers. Additionally, everyone was so incredibly supportive of me in particular, which felt important as it become more and more apparent that Ms. Newkirk and a few of her supporters were treating me differently (um, less human) because of the junk in my trunk. Though I'm actually MORE disgusted with the uncritical, self-righteous, privileged stance of PETA after last night, I am proud of what we pulled off, proud of my amazing friends and allies, and proud of the feminist spirit that kept us awesome.
Because many of Ms. Newkirk's audience members were confused about our stance, let me lay out a few things:*We were not protesting the care and compassion for animals that is important to PETA and other animal rights activist groups. Many of us are vegan/vegetarian and have engaged in animal rights activism.
*We don't believe that to question another activist's practice or theoretical approach means we are discounting their cause, de facto.
*We believe that all radical, progressive social movements should be self-reflective, accountable and aware of privilege. Members of said movements need to be willing to consider their blind spots and engage in productive dialogue with other concerned human beings. I'm not sure how radical and progressive a movement is if its members are unwilling to think about these things.
*Caring about the treatment of women and the treatment of animals are not in binary opposition. There's no need to choose one over the other. This isn't rocket science.
So, we showed up last night a little early to make some signs and tell some jokes about misogyny and backwards politics. It helped. Not because we think we're more important than anyone, but because how else can one deal with an aggressive, public attack on one's dignity and self-worth? Through humor, obviously. Someone from the Mercury interviewed me, and though I really can't remember what I said in my adrenaline induced high, I trust that it made sense and packed a punch. I do remember that my protest friends rolled out some brilliant comments for her as well, a fact which bolstered me.
We headed over to Powell's, our signs rolled up neatly in our bags, our feminist hearts beating perhaps a little faster. I, for one, felt keyed up, nervous, excited. I entertained fleeting thoughts such as, "yes, that's right a.holes - the fat girl is protesting fat jokes - yuck it up" and "I could never have done this ten years ago" and "don't cry, ERF." But, with the crew of smart, funny, supportive people around me, I let those thoughts come and go, and I kept walking. I thought about how, just like whales and turkeys and various other farm animals, I have feelings and emotions that can be hurt by human cruelty. Mostly, though, I thought about how good it feels to care about something and know that other people care about it, too. I felt thankful for all of the sap and emotion that takes me over at least once a day, helping me to feel compassionately connected to humanity, and even the animal kingdom. I'd rather care deeply about the world and risk getting hurt than be apathetic. It's a worthwhile venture.
At the talk, we filed in to our rows of folding chairs, respectfully listening as Ms. Newkirk spoke about kindness, compassion, and the interconnectedness of animal rights and environmentalism to the visibly white audience. She suggested that we nag people in our lives until they care about animal rights. Then she played a cloying (albeit cute) montage film of animals being adorable. Who doesn't like adorable animals? Of course I teared up at the clip of two horses that appeared to be in love, in spite of the fact that I felt absolutely disgusted that this woman could speak so sincerely about kindness while promoting a hateful advertising campaign. We all waited expectantly for the question and answer period, where we hoped to illicit some public dialogue with Ms. Newkirk. That moment never came.
Much to our surprise, Ms. Newkirk moved swiftly to book signing. A Willamette Week reporter approached our group, asking if we were going to protest, make some noise. Without losing a beat, we marched silently to the front of the room, lining up against the wall to the side of Ms. Newkirk's table, our signs over our chests like (come on, let me nerd out) sloppy badges of courage. People stared, took photos, whispered to each other in small clumps, looked confused. Some punk kids and white folks with dreads and thin bodies suggested we protest something "more offensive" than PETA, wanted to have heated conversation with us about how wrong we were. Everyone in our group remained calm and polite. In the meantime, one of our group approached Ms. Newkirk as she signed her treatise on kindness and compassion, attempting to have a civil conversation with her about sexism and fat phobia in PETA's ad campaigns. Ms. Newkirk asked that we wait to talk until after the signing, presumably when her adoring fans were out of ear shot. A Powell's employee, who was undoubtedly just doing her job, became red in the face as she insisted that we leave because this "wasn't our event." Apparently we were an unsightly distraction. We got kicked out of Powell's!
We walked through the catacombs of books to the front entrance, signs extended, where we waited for audience members to exit. We talked and talked and talked to people with questions and furrowed brows. Most people were earnestly interested in our platform, and the majority of people that we spoke to were able to see why PETA's insistence in objectifying women's bodies like meat is troubling and, frankly, UNETHICAL. Some people were inexplicably mad (muttering venom as they passed through our wall o'feminist epithets), though they hadn't even been at the PETA talk. Most people were peaceful and respectful.

And then, things got philosophically gross. I have to go to work and live my life, so please stay tuned for "Confirmed: Ms. Newkirk Hates Fat People" and "Ms. Newkirk Supporter Tries to Make Me Cry." You won't be disappointed. Or, actually, you will be incredibly disappointed.